The Toronto Maple Leafs have stumbled upon the NHL’s most enviable problem: they have too much talent in the crease. With the rapid emergence of Dennis Hildeby, the Leafs effectively have three NHL-caliber goaltenders, turning veteran Anthony Stolarz from a necessity into a massive trade chip.
Nick Kypreos recently dropped a bombshell on the Real Kyper & Bourne Show, placing Stolarz firmly on his trade board. The destination that screams logical fit? The Philadelphia Flyers.
This isn’t just idle chatter. As teams emerge from the Olympic break, the market for stability in net is shrinking, and the Flyers are desperate for a reliable No. 1. For the first time in years, Toronto GM Brad Treliving holds massive leverage. He doesn’t need to trade Stolarz, but if Philadelphia calls with a desperate offer, the Leafs might just be able to upgrade their roster significantly by moving a goalie they no longer rely on to save their season.
Analyzing the Fit: Why Philadelphia Needs This Move
From my vantage point as a longtime observer of the league, the Flyers are in a precarious position. Since the departure of Carter Hart, Philadelphia has been hunting for consistency. They have a competitive roster that works hard under Rick Tocchet, but goaltending volatility has capped their ceiling.
This is where the Anthony Stolarz connection becomes fascinating. Stolarz was originally drafted by the Flyers (2012, 2nd round). He knows the market, he knows the pressure, and at 31 years old, he has matured into a statistically elite goaltender.
We aren’t talking about a fringe backup here. Last season, Stolarz posted a league-best .926 save percentage and a 2.14 GAA alongside four shutouts. He has proven he can handle the workload. For Philadelphia, acquiring Stolarz isn’t just a rental for a playoff push; with four years remaining on his contract at a $3.75M AAV, it’s a solution for the half-decade. That is the kind of cost certainty that GMs drool over in a flat-cap era.
The Leafs’ Leverage and “The Hildeby Effect”
The only reason we are having this conversation is Dennis Hildeby. If the “Hildebeast” wasn’t looking NHL-ready, Stolarz would be untouchable. But the reality of the salary cap is that you cannot allocate nearly $4 million to a third-string goalie or a 1B option if you have a younger, cheaper option ready to go.
Kypreos noting that the Leafs have a “legit luxury” is the key here. Toronto can wait. If Stolarz plays lights out after the break, his price goes up. If he struggles, the Leafs simply keep him as the best insurance policy in the league.
However, if I’m the Leafs’ front office, I am looking at the Flyers’ blueline or their prospect pool and wondering if a swap helps my playoff run more than a third goalie does. Stolarz’s value may never be higher than it is right now. He looks like the goalie teams remember, and in the NHL, memory often dictates the market price.
Latest Leafs News, Playoff Pool
Want to stay ahead of every trade rumor before the deadline? Make sure to bookmark nhltraderumor.com for breaking updates on the Toronto Maple Leafs and the rest of the league. While you’re here, don’t miss out on our NHL Playoff Hockey Pool—sign up today for a chance to win huge cash prizes!
Don’t forget to join the inner circle of hockey fans by subscribing below.
The post Is Stolarz Done in Toronto? Why a Flyers Trade Makes Perfect Sense appeared first on NHL Trade Rumors.
