The panic in Leafs Nation is palpable, and frankly, it’s justified. If Chris Tanev’s groin injury is as serious as the rumorsa suggest, the Toronto Maple Leafs aren’t just looking for a replacement; they are staring into a defensive abyss. The rumor mill has exploded with names ranging from Jason Robertson to a reunion with Luke Schenn, but let’s cut through the noise. Brad Treliving is under immense pressure, but making a move out of desperation is exactly how this franchise has mortgaged its future for decades without a Cup to show for it. Before you get excited about the big names floating around, you need to hear the hard truth about what it will actually cost to fix this blue line.
Analyzing the Targets: Andersson, Faulk, and the Return of Luke Schenn?
As an analyst watching the market heat up, the connection to names like Brandon Montour and Jamie Oleksiak—as reported by Nick Kypreos—signals that the Leafs are swinging for the fences. But the report from Terry Koshan of the Toronto Sun is where the rubber meets the road. If Tanev is done for the season, Treliving is practically forced to shop for a right-shot defenseman.
Koshan threw out a laundry list of options: Rasmus Andersson, Justin Faulk, Luke Schenn, Tyler Myers, Mario Ferraro, and Connor Murphy. Here is my personal insight: Buyer Beware.
Let’s look at Justin Faulk. On paper, he stabilizes the right side. In reality? Taking on a 34-year-old with a $6.5 million cap hit through 2026-27 is a salary cap death sentence. We have seen this movie before. The Leafs acquire a veteran on the decline, the contract ages like milk, and we spend the next three years trying to pay someone to take it off our hands.
Rasmus Andersson is the dream target, but he is likely out of the Maple Leafs’ price range. The cost of doing business for a top-tier RHD right now starts with a first-round pick and likely includes Easton Cowan. Let me be clear: Easton Cowan should be untouchable. The Leafs have bled draft capital and prospects for years in “all-in” moves that resulted in one playoff round win. Trading your best prospect (Cowan) or a promising defender like Ben Danford for a rental or an aging veteran is insanity.
This brings us to Luke Schenn. He is the most affordable option at $2.75 million and brings that heavy, playoff-style game the Leafs covet. But is he a needle-mover? No. He’s a band-aid.
The uncomfortable reality that fans might need to accept is that Troy Stecher, plucked off waivers in November, might be the most significant addition this blueline gets. The Leafs simply do not have the assets to land a big fish without gutting the few pieces of future potential they have left. If Tanev is out, the answer isn’t to light the future on fire—it’s to find a way to survive with what you have.
Latest Toronto Maple Leafs News, Fantasy Pools, and TV Schedule
Stay ahead of every rumor and roster move by checking our website daily for the latest Toronto Maple Leafs news. Think you know more than the GM? Prove it. Join our Fantasy Hockey Pool for a chance to win cash prizes and bragging rights. Also, don’t miss a second of the action—find out exactly how to watch the Leafs game on TV today on our schedule page. Make sure to add nhltraderumor.com to your bookmarks and sign up for our newsletter below.
The post Are the Toronto Maple Leafs About to Make a Massive Trade Mistake? appeared first on NHL Trade Rumors.
