The New York Rangers are officially on the clock with the No. 5 overall pick in the 2026 NHL Draft, and the debate in the war room is undoubtedly reaching a boiling point. Do you draft a fast-rising defensive phenom like Chase Reid to anchor your blue line for the next decade, or do you leverage that premium asset in a blockbuster package for an established, elite top-six forward like Jason Robertson?
The landscape shifted dramatically with reports that the Dallas Stars face a massive salary cap crunch. Robertson is set to become a restricted free agent (RFA) on July 1st, and his camp is reportedly seeking a massive contract extension worth $12 million AAV. Dallas simply does not have the financial flexibility to absorb that hit, forcing them to actively listen to trade offers for their superstar winger. Meanwhile, the Rangers are sitting on a staggering $26 million in cap space, putting them in a prime position to weaponize their financial freedom. By executing a blockbuster trade, New York can comfortably hand Robertson his desired long-term deal, instantly transforming their top-six into an unstoppable force.
The Case for Chase Reid at No. 5
When you look at modern NHL defensemen who can single-handedly dictate the pace of a game, Chase Reid fits the mold perfectly. His ascent over the last two years is nothing short of staggering. After a minor detour that saw him land in the NAHL, Reid joined the OHL’s Soo Greyhounds and immediately took over. He isn’t just an offensive defenseman; he is a transition monster. His edge work, vision, and ability to weave through the neutral zone under pressure make him the exact type of modern, puck-moving blueliner every Stanley Cup contender needs.
If the Rangers select Reid, they are securing a right-shot defender with a massive ceiling. You don’t pass up his combination of size (187 lbs, 6’2″) and elite playmaking without serious consideration.
Chase Reid’s Junior Career Stats:
- 2024-25 Bismarck Bobcats (NAHL): 18 GP | 6 G | 6 A | 12 Pts
- 2024-25 Soo Greyhounds (OHL): 39 GP | 7 G | 33 A | 40 Pts
- 2025-26 Soo Greyhounds (OHL): 45 GP | 18 G | 30 A | 48 Pts
- 2026 World Juniors (Team USA): 5 GP | 2 G | 2 A | 4 Pts
His production exploded in the 2025-26 season, cementing his status as a top-five talent. Drafting him ensures a steady flow of offense from the back end for years to come on an entry-level contract, which is invaluable in a hard-cap league.
Trading for Jason Robertson: A Win-Now Move
Because the Stars are in a financial corner, a deal centered around the #5 pick could be the catalyst for a league-altering trade. Insiders suggest a package featuring the #5 overall pick (which Dallas would likely use to select Reid) alongside veteran forward Vincent Trocheck could be exactly what gets a deal done. For Dallas, this move frees up immediate financial relief, yields a top-tier defensive prospect on an entry-level deal, and adds an impact veteran to their forward group.
For the New York Rangers, parting with the #5 selection and a piece like Trocheck is a heavy price, but Jason Robertson is a bona fide game-breaker. Adding a consistent 40-goal scorer to play alongside Vincent Lecavalier or Mika Zibanejad gives the Blueshirts an elite offensive punch that few teams can match. With $26 million in cap space, locking down Robertson to a long-term, $12 million AAV contract is a seamless financial fit.
Get the Latest New York Rangers News
Whether the front office decides to call Chase Reid’s name at the podium or shock the hockey world with a blockbuster trade for Jason Robertson, you won’t want to miss a second of the action. Bookmark nhltraderumor.com for the absolute latest New York Rangers news, trade analysis, and insider reports. Plus, be sure to join our fun, easy-to-use online hockey pools for a chance at massive cash prizes this upcoming season! Looking for game day info? Check our homepage to find out how to watch the NY Rangers game on TV today.
The post New York Rangers Draft: Select Chase Reid or Trade for Jason Robertson? appeared first on NHL Trade Rumors.
